« Workplace Issues - Can You Say The "N" Word? | Main | Living On A Budget - Accomodations »

March 25, 2005

Workplace Issues - Can A Student Be Your Friend?

Readers,

Tell me if you’ve ever had a day like this. You’ve got a million things to do, clean your house, take your car in for servicing, buy dog food…you get the picture. Anyway, as soon as you’re showered and ready to head out the door, you hear a timid knock. Before you even answer it, your heart sinks because you know who it is.

The Student Who Wants To Be Your Friend.

Now, I’m not saying that I don’t absolutely love my students—I do, but at times I would like to make the line much clearer between my teaching time and my personal time. Any ESL teacher knows that time is precious because we generally end up working a ton of hours. Because of this I’ve come to absolutely guard my free time. That is, until this one particular student came into my life.

Sigh.

The hard part for me is that whenever he comes to my house to chat (read: practice his English for free), I instantly feel that I’m back on the job. He’s half my age, so we don’t exactly have tons in common for a perky conversation, and quite frankly, my idea of a great time isn’t hanging out with a teenage boy.

So, what should I do? He’s a great guy who sincerely wants to develop a friendship with me, and I feel like a heel for not wanting to respond in kind. But come on…I’ve got dog food to buy.

Living in a foreign land throws an entirely different aspect into the argument for several reasons. First of all, oftentimes, those students are the only people we know in the country and unless we want to hang out by ourselves every day, we tend to accept offers of dinner at their houses, etc. And that’s not bad, considering that it’s a great way to experience the culture firsthand.

But then those knocks on the door start at the most inopportune times…

What do you think? Do you believe that it’s a good idea to make friends with your students? Write me and tell me what you’ve done in situations like this!

I want to thank everyone who has written in with great comments over the past few weeks. I love to read your ideas and input on the situations—keep them coming!

Well, I’d better run. I hear someone at the door…

Until next time,

Michelle

Posted by msimmons at March 25, 2005 01:49 AM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.esl-lesson-plan.com/mt-tb.cgi/17

Comments

Concerning your friendly student. I am a male teacher and I used to be invited to my students' homes but I would never allow them to come to mine. I never went to a female student's home. A female teacher may go to a female student's home but it is rather naive to go to a male student's home and any students arriving at the doorstep, should be told, in no uncertain terms, to go away. Especially, if it is a male student, going to a female teacher's home. It may be embarrassing to tell a student, not to come again, after he has been coming to the teacher's home for some considerable time, but he has to be told that circumstances have now changed and it is not now convenient for him to call. It would have been better if the rules had been made clear at the beginning of the classes, so that there can be no misunderstanding.

Posted by: Kenneth Cohan at March 26, 2005 03:56 PM

I just had to laugh while I was reading yout post. I so comprehend what you feel! At the moment I am teaching Masters' students in China, oral English, in which the situation is very similar to yours - over friendly students. It is even more difficult for me however, as I am a female teacher who has just graduated from University in Australia. As a result, the postgraduate students i teach are either my age or even older than me. The advantage is that I can develop a good rapport with them, however the disadvantage is that they all want to be my friend. In most cases, I am extremely happy to develop a friendship with them. However there have been a few which have really tested my tolerance level. I am already extremely clear and strict with my principles - no.1 I do not go out/ eat out alone with male students (this is not only due to respect to my BF but also for my own safety and to avoid any unecessary trouble), no.2 Male students are definitely not welcome at my apartment.

So far the female students have been great and I really enjoy getting to know them. However, I have a certain male student who makes it quite obvious that he wants to be more than friends - despite the fact that I continually go on about my BF! Most students in China are rather conservative, so the good thing is that they will not invite themselves to my apartment. Luckily this male student hasn't either. The one mistake I may have made though is giving the students my cell phone number when they asked for it. As a result, I was at one stage bombarded with SMS, particularly from this student! There were also many dinner and lunch invites - in which i did go to once at a restaurant, together with another female restaurant, the rest I declined. Particularly as i found out later that this student wanted a bit more than friendship. It got to a point that i blunty told the student that the invites could not go on anymore - particularly because i already have a BF etc. From his response, I don't think this student understood.

Later on I found out that there are many young people in China between the age of 20-30 who couldn't care less if you already have a partner or even if you are married! They believe that they still have that one percent chance with you. For many of the students, it is a ticket to freedom - that they may get a chance to go overseas. They also admire foreigners. (I am sure that this is the case not only in China but also elsewhere in the world). Which explains the persistence of this male student. I have heard that the female students come on even stronger however! So male teachers beware!

Of course there are those who are genunie and pure in their friendship, but there are also many who are otherwise.

As for the male student, I have started to ignore his messages and I am definite I will not give him any opportunities to develop his intentions. I've found that the ignoring works - I just have to think of what to say next when I see him......

Posted by: pam at April 1, 2005 08:46 AM

I think you are being rather naive. I'm sure he appreciates the free English practice, but teenage boys visiting their older female teachers do not just want to be "friends". I'm sure you have been professional in your behavior, so he probably realizes that there isn't any hope for what he really wants, but you need to put a stop to this...pronto. Please forgive me for being so blunt.

Posted by: Laura at April 1, 2005 10:27 PM

I agree with Kenneth. Inviting either a male or female student to your home is not a good idea. As you have already experienced.

In any case,we should treat all students equally. If one is allowed to visit why isn't another. Students talk and gossip to each other. They know what is going on. Favoring one and not another will cause friction in the classroom.

I am a popular teacher. My students are always asking to visit me, to have my phone number or e-mail address. I always decline by explaining that it wouldn't be fair because I would have to give my address and phone number to everyone else. It's not practical. They accept my explanation without a problem.

I love teaching, but when Í'm free I want to relax and enjoy thinking about and doing things unrelated to my work. This way I am always fresh and eager to teach.

Hope this helps.

Posted by: Jennifer at April 2, 2005 11:37 AM

I enjoyed reading your stuff. Cool site. Naked truth: http://johnedithnotes.blogspot.com/2005/10/slatecom.html , 1 small clove garlic

Posted by: Bryan Taylor at October 7, 2005 05:21 PM

thanks god i found you guys ,i`m a non native speaker who teaches English one of my students is pushing me to go uot , what can i do ?
i don`t wanna hurt him?

Posted by: gregoria at October 22, 2007 07:19 PM

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)