« Industry Events- 2007 AMTESOL Conference | Main | Q and A: Can I take my pet abroad? »
December 04, 2006
Surveys- English Only Classrooms
Hello Readers,
There's a hot debate going on among many ESL teachers, and that is whether we should allow the students or ourselves to speak their mother tongue in the classroom. What's your experience? Do you allow other languages to be used in your classroom...
...or do you have an English-only classroom?
To answer this survey, please go to http://www.esl-jobs-forum.com/viewtopic.php?p=3371#3371
Don't forget that you'll have to either register or log in before you can take part in the poll. (But don't worry, it's free!)
Question: Do you have an English-only classroom?
1) Yes
2) No
3) Usually
-----> Please enter YOUR answer
Anything missing from the above choices? Feel free to share additional ideas by commenting below!
I look forward to reading your answers soon!
Carol Rueckert
Writer, ESL Lesson Plan
E-mail: crueckert@eslemployment.com
Blog: www.esl-lesson-plan.com"I hear, and I forget. I see, and I remember. I do, and I understand." - Chinese Proverb
*Looking for other interesting surveys (and their resultes) about the ESL industry? Click HERE!
-----------
About the author of this entry:
Carol, a native English-speaker who hails from the small town of St. Joseph in Minnesota, USA, and lived and worked in China for more than 7 years. During that time, she worked with students that range in age from three to more than sixty years old. She worked in universities, private language schools, grade schools, international schools, as well as private tutoring. Besides teaching, she also worked as a head teacher, an education manager, and a material development manager. In addition to working on this newsletter, she currently writes a monthly column for Time Out Beijing. Carol is also currently working on her MA in TESOL at the Oxford Brookes University in England. Look for her posts on the ESL-Jobs-Forum discussion boards!
Posted by crueckert at December 4, 2006 04:37 AM
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.esl-lesson-plan.com/mt-tb.cgi/211
Comments
I allow anything the students want to use. and I will even encourage it by askin "how do you say this" in another language. I think it shows the students we aren't imperialists and rather than trying to replace their language they are adding to it.
Posted by: Landry at December 5, 2006 11:01 PM
I'm a definite believer in running as much of the class in the target language as possible-- even when I was a low-intermediate student of mandarin, I quite deliberately hired a Chinese middle-school teacher who couldn't speak any English at all as my tutor.
Speaking your mother tongue (or expecting it) in class is kind of like paying for a book of crossword puzzles and peeking at the answers at the back before you've finished.
That's WHY different levels of classes exist--- to have graded levels of what some might call 'positive stress'. If a student can't understand something in class, they should make a note of it, as best as they can, and then move on. Learning to be cool with stuff that you don't understand is part of the process.
Posted by: Ray at December 6, 2006 10:57 AM
I try to have an English-only classroom.The students are there to learn English and every minute must be used for this. It is an opportunity for them to practice what they have learned. Outside the classroom they will speak only their native language anyway. So, even if they have a difficult time, I think they also enjoy this English-only policy. My Filipino students welcome this because outside the classroom they can get criticized for being elitists of sorts. My Korean and Chinese students have a more difficult time. They are very dependent on their electronic dictionaries. However, I likewise do not allow them to speak in their native language and they are doing fine.
Because the students receive a mark for the course, I offer a 10 point bonus to those students I never catch speaking in another language. The number of violations have equivalent bonus points. They are not to exceed 8 violations because if they do, they will have no more bonus points.
When I catch a student speaking in his native language, I give him a tag. If he hears another student speaking his native language, he passes the tag to this student. This goes on during the class period. Everytime a student receives the tag, he writes his name on the board under the list of "Violators". At the end of the period, I copy the list into my record book.
Posted by: Maria Francisca Viado at December 6, 2006 07:53 PM
I'm from Macedonia. You can do something here. Some kind of project, has so many who speak english and whowant to speak.You can check our knowledge with some test and we can learn more.
I want to have colaboration with someone.We live only 13 km from Greece and speak greek well. Try something here.Macedonia is small but has a clever people.
Merry XMAS and happy NEW YEAR to all of you.
Jasmina Milevska
Posted by: Jasmina at December 26, 2006 06:46 AM








